The Three Stages to a Magento to Shopify Migration

Frame left Orange Collar Media - Frame Left
Frame right Orange Collar Media - Frame Right

5 min read min read | January 30, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • A successful Magento to Shopify migration follows three key stages: organizing your store, redesigning the storefront, and setting up payments
  • You can either connect your existing domain to Shopify or transfer it completely - customers won't notice the difference
  • Migration is the perfect opportunity to fix customer journey issues and refresh your store design with Shopify's mobile-optimized themes
  • Thorough testing of your payment system after migration is critical - test multiple times before going live
  • Shopify offers a 14-day free trial to test the platform before committing to a migration

So, you've made the decision to migrate your site. After considering all the benefits of Shopify, it's time to bite the bullet and make the move. You're poised, ready... So, what's next? You need to know what to expect from a Magento to Shopify migration.

There are three stepping stones to a Magento to Shopify migration.

  1. Organizing your store. Transferring your domain, customer accounts, content and data, and setting up URL redirects.
  2. Looking good. Use the opportunity to design a visually appealing store that supports a great user journey.
  3. Getting paid. Your payments, shipping, taxes and testing orders.

Step 1: Get Organized

Organizing your store requires you to be, well, organized. In a migration, you'll be taking all of the data from one site to another, and you might not realize how much information you have until you begin the process. Transferring data can be time consuming, and can get messy if you don't keep track of where you are and what's important.

You want a seamless transition of data, not a mismatched, confused mess. So, start by categorizing what you have. This might be as simple as listing all your 'areas' of content e.g. blog, products, historical orders, promotional codes, landing pages. Place an order of importance on each area, and break it down into a rough timeline. Then, you're ready to get started.

Transfer Your Domain

Unless you're also going through a re-brand, chances are you want to keep your domain name. It makes it easier for your existing customers, keeps your comms consistent and saves you any unnecessary hassle. Shopify has two ways of keeping your domain name in the 'big move'. You can connect your domain name, or you can transfer it.

Connect. When you connect your domain name, it's still in the hands of your third-party domain host. Shopify simply overlays your domain name onto your Shopify store.

Transfer. Your domain is shifted to Shopify. That means you pay for it and renew through Shopify admin. It's no longer connected to a third party.

Your customers won't know the difference, whichever option you go for. Your store will still be located at the same site address they know and trust. So, you can make a choice based on your personal preference.

It's really important to check that your domain (your site URL) is connected in Shopify. You can check that your IP address has migrated over by clicking on the domain status.

Drowning in domain admin? Get someone else to do the heavy lifting. Our team are experts in Magento to Shopify migrations.

Step 2: Store Makeover

A Magento to Shopify migration is the perfect opportunity to have a storefront revamp. Not only will it generate a bit of a buzz around your newly updated shop for your customers, it's a great chance to sound-out and fix any customer journey issues from your previous site. You might, for example, have made a lot of Magento changes that, over the years, have stacked up on top of each other in order to streamline the user journey. Now's the chance to tackle them from the start and tidy up behind the scenes.

Shopify has plenty of free themes available (under admin), so you can beautify your store quickly and painlessly. There's also a lot of paid-for themes - and Shopify let you test these out for free before you make any paid commitments. So have a play and see what works best for your brand and the integrations you'll want to use.

Want a bespoke website based on your customer personas and user journey data? Let the experts cast their eye and help maximize your Shopify migration.

Step 3: Revenue Through Shopify

The last stage is, arguably, the most important. It's how you get paid. Transfer your payment provider from Magento to Shopify. Or you can choose a new one through Shopify and integrate it all under one roof. One of Shopify's greatest strengths is its capacity for testing. You can test out numerous features and integrations and then go back, tweak, refine or undo them completely. You can do this with payments. Be your customer. Once your accounts, payments and shipping has migrated test and test again. You know what, test a third time too. After a migration, your payment system needs to be seamless or you risk losing customers.

Shipping taxes are automatically calculated by Shopify, and if you need to override them, there's an option to adjust them manually. When it comes to security, Shopify really has put this high on the agenda. There's inbuilt fraud analysis for your payment peace of mind.

Ready for Lift-Off?

First thing's first. Find out if Shopify is a best-fit for you. Make the most of its 14-day free trial and the testing application to really get under Shopify's skin. You can transfer data, test out processes and integrations, undo the tests and start again - all without impacting your store.

Get Expert Help with Your Migration

Do you have an eCommerce site that needs more than a basic approach? Our team specializes in seamless migrations from Magento to Shopify. We also offer Adobe Commerce support if you're exploring enterprise-level options. Contact us today to discuss your migration project and get a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a Magento to Shopify migration take?

Migration timelines vary based on store complexity, but most migrations take 2-8 weeks. Simple stores with fewer products can migrate faster, while large catalogs with extensive customizations require more time for proper data transfer and testing.

Will I lose my SEO rankings during migration?

With proper URL redirects and SEO planning, you can preserve most of your search rankings. The key is implementing 301 redirects for all old URLs and maintaining your meta data, titles, and content structure where possible.

Can I transfer my customer accounts from Magento to Shopify?

Yes, customer data including names, emails, addresses, and order history can be migrated. However, passwords cannot be transferred for security reasons, so customers will need to reset their passwords on first login.

What data can be migrated from Magento to Shopify?

Most critical data can be migrated including products, categories, customers, order history, blog posts, and pages. Some Magento-specific features may need alternative solutions in Shopify's app ecosystem.

Do I need to redesign my store when migrating to Shopify?

While not required, migration is an excellent opportunity to refresh your design. Shopify offers hundreds of professionally designed themes that are mobile-optimized and conversion-focused, often improving upon legacy Magento designs.

How do I handle product variants during migration?

Shopify handles product variants differently than Magento. Products with up to 100 variants migrate smoothly, but configurable products with more options may need restructuring or third-party apps to maintain full functionality.